Skip to main content

Table 1 Summary of metaproteomic studies of human gut microbiota

From: Metaproteomic analysis of human gut microbiota: where are we heading?

Sample type

Subject

Separation method

Mass spectrometer

Database

No. of proteins identified

Reference

Feces

2 infants

2-D PAGE

MALDI-TOF

Public database

>200 spots, 1 protein identified

Klaassens et al., 2007

Feces

1 infant

2D-LC

LTQ Orbitrap

Databases from metagenomic sequences, microbial species, human and common contaminants

4,031 proteins

Young et al., 2015

Feces

1 monozygotic twin pair (adult)

2D-LC

LTQ Orbitrap

Databases from two human metagenomes, human database and common contaminants

446 human proteins

1,368 microbial proteins

Verberkmoes et al., 2009

Feces

3 healthy adults

1-DE and LC

LTQ Orbitrap

Databases from intestinal microbes, two metagenomes, human protein and food database

1,790 proteins

Kolmeder et al., 2012

Mucosal lavage

38 healthy adults

LC

WCX magnetic beads

LTQ Orbitrap

MALDI-TOF

Swiss-Prot

300 human proteins

Li et al., 2011

Feces

1 adult with antibiotic treatment

1-DE and LC

LTQ Orbitrap

Matched metagenome

3,011 proteins

Pérez-Cobas et al., 2013

Feces

6 monozygotic twin pairs (1 set healthy, 3 sets concordant twins with CD, 2 sets discordant twins)

2D-LC

LTQ Orbitrap

Matched metagenome and human microbial isolate reference genome database

2,904 proteins

Erickson et al., 2012

Mucosal lavage

First cohort: 3 healthy, 6 UC patients

Second cohort: 13 healthy, 14 CD, 15 UC

WCX Protein Chip arrays

SELDI-TOF

Uniprot

589 proteins

Presley et al., 2012

Mucosal lavage

Discovery cohort: 51 (17 healthy, 13 UC, 21 CD)

Validation cohort: 38 healthy

WCX magnetic beads

LC

MALDI-TOF

LTQ Orbitrap

Swiss-Prot

599 protein/peptide peaks

Li et al., 2016

Feces

1 lean and 1 obese teenager

1-DE and LC

LTQ Orbitrap

Matched and unmatched metagenomes

613 proteins

Ferrer et al., 2013

Feces

9 normal, 4 overweight, 16 obese

1-DE and LC

Orbitrap

In-house metaproteome database

893,007 MS/MS spectra

Kolmeder et al., 2015

Feces

3 liver cirrhosis patients and their corresponding spouse

1-DE and LC

Quadrupole-Orbitrap

UniProt

5,020 proteins

Wei et al., 2016

Feces

15 children with cystic fibrosis and their unaffected siblings

1-DE and LC

Ion trap-FTICR

NCBI

1,676 proteins

Debyser et al., 2016

Feces

16 healthy adults (8 probiotics, 8 placebo)

1-DE and LC

LTQ Orbitrap

In-house metaproteome database

4,966 peptides

Kolmeder et al., 2016

Feces

1 healthy adult

LC

LTQ Orbitrap

UniProtKB

Swiss-Prot

3,911 proteins (not centrifuged)

4,587 proteins (centrifuged)

Tanca et al., 2015

Feces

2 premature infants

2D-LC

LTQ Orbitrap

In-house metaproteome database

807 and 342 proteins (without filtering)

1264 and 1012 proteins (with double filtering)

Xiong et al., 2015b

Feces

2 healthy adults

1-DE and LC

LTQ Orbitrap

Matched metagenomes

Synthetic metagenomes (iterative search)

2,331 and 1,870 peptides

5,010 and 3,542 peptides

Rooijers et al., 2011

Feces

4 healthy volunteers

LC

LTQ Orbitrap

Metagenome databases UniProt-based databases

All bacterial sequences

>10,000 peptides

Tanca et al., 2016

Feces

Mucosal lavage

8 mice

8 pediatric volunteers

LC

Q Exactive

Microbial

gene catalog databases

Target-decoy database

30,749 mouse protein groups

19,011 human protein groups

Zhang et al., 2016b

Mucosal lavage

5 teenagers

LC

LTQ Orbitrap

In-house Human Intestinal

Microbial Protein Database

Target-decoy database

4,014 protein groups quantified

Zhang et al., 2016a

  1. 1-DE one-dimensional electrophoresis, 2-D PAGE two-dimensional polyacrylamide gel electrophoresis, 2-D LC two-dimensional liquid chromatography, FTICR Fourier transform ion cyclotron resonance, LC liquid chromatography, LTQ linear trap quadrupole, MALDI-TOF matrix-assisted laser desorption/ionization time-of-flight, NCBI National Center for Biotechnology Information, SELDI-TOF surface-enhanced laser desorption/ionization time-of-flight, WCX weak cation exchange